Skip to content

Guides · sequence of returns risk

Sequence of Returns Risk in Early Retirement

Why a market fall early in retirement can sink a plan that average returns say is fine, with a worked example and the main ways FIRE planners reduce the risk.

Sequence of Returns Risk in Early Retirement. Capability illustrations. Sample data, not a live account.

Order matters once you withdraw

While you are saving, the order of returns does not change where you end up: the same returns in any order give the same growth. Once you are withdrawing, it does. Selling assets after a fall locks in the loss, and the money sold is no longer there for the recovery. Poor returns in the first years of retirement do much more damage than the same returns later.

A worked example

Two retirees each start with $1,000,000 and withdraw $40,000 a year. Both see the same returns over two years: a 20% fall and a 20% gain. The first gets the fall first: $1,000,000 − $40,000 = $960,000, falls to $768,000, minus $40,000 is $728,000, then grows to $873,600. The second gets the gain first: $960,000 grows to $1,152,000, minus $40,000 is $1,112,000, then falls to $889,600.

Same returns, same withdrawals, and the first retiree is $16,000 behind after two years. Over a long downturn the gap can decide whether the money lasts.

Ways to reduce the risk

A lower withdrawal rate

Withdrawing 3% to 3.5% instead of 4% leaves more assets to recover after a fall.

Flexible spending

Cutting discretionary spending in bad years means selling fewer assets at low prices.

A cash or bond buffer

One to three years of spending in cash or short bonds can pay for living costs while stocks recover. A bond tent raises bonds around the retirement date and lowers them later.

Some income

Part-time work in the first years of retirement covers spending exactly when the risk is highest.

Where 1cc.ai fits

Runway after salary stops

The app estimates how long assets last once salary stops, using an assumed return and inflation. It uses a constant return, so it does not model a bad sequence; test a lower return to see one.

Market context

US Treasury yields, the yield curve and market sentiment sit beside your holdings in the same app.

FIRE planning, net worth, options and markets.

A FIRE date, estimated from your portfolio.

Choose a spending scenario from lean to abundant and a 3–4% withdrawal rate to set target assets. See the estimated FIRE month and age in today's money, test a monthly contribution change, and check how long assets last after salary stops.

Spending that sets the FIRE target.

Ongoing monthly expenses set the current spending level for FIRE, and recurring income minus recurring expenses sets the monthly net contribution. Balances in other currencies are converted with the exchange rate shown.

Frequently asked questions

What is sequence of returns risk?

The risk that poor returns arrive early in retirement, while you are withdrawing, so that you sell assets at low prices and the portfolio runs out sooner than average returns would suggest.

Why is sequence risk worse for early retirees?

Their money has to last longer, often 40 years or more, so an early loss has more years to compound against them, and they have usually left the income that could refill the portfolio.

What is a bond tent?

An allocation that holds more bonds in the years around retirement and moves back toward stocks later, so less has to be sold from stocks if the market falls early on.

Does the 1cc.ai FIRE projection include sequence risk?

No. It uses one constant return and one inflation rate. To see the effect of weaker markets, lower the assumed return and compare the dates.

Is a FIRE projection a guarantee?

No. A FIRE projection is a scenario built on assumed returns and inflation, not a forecast or a guaranteed return. Markets do not deliver a constant return.